I had an interesting discussion tonight with someone who thinks that regulating industry is a great evil.
This person also seemed to think that when something is being done wrong, it is a simple matter to report it. Were that the case, we would not need Whistle Blower laws to protect the innocent. Without them, people who did make reports had the tendency to be not only fired, but blackballed in their "industry", so they could never work again. But even with the Whistle Blower laws, it's not an easy task.
Some towns have EXACTLY one industry. It may in fact be the ONLY employer in an entire county. I recall one incident in Iowa, where a local paint company was running unhealthy toxin levels IN their factory. The EPA team that went to do the testing had to LEAVE the building after only five minutes, because they were getting faint and dizzy from the fumes. Now most companies KNOW when the EPA is coming to test...this one did. But it had been so long since they were compliant to the regs, they had no idea what level was acceptable. They talked to workers, and found out most of them were sick a lot...but since it WAS the only employer, and actually owned the only bank in town...well...it wasn't healthy to piss them off.
But someone finally stood up. No...they were not following OSHA rules...but OSHA has a very small staff to regulate EVERY industry that exists in the US. The companies count on that.
Now I offer the Town of Libby Montana.
http://www.epa.gov/libby/
http://voices.yahoo.com/libby-montana-declared-environmental-disaster-area-3585191.html
Two hundred people died as a result of exposure to the asbestos there....another 1000 are ill.
The population of Libby is currently about 2600.
So give or take HALF the town was effected.
The asbestos came from the SOLE industry in the town...a mining operation. Just about everyone worked there. There were no alternatives.
If you check the links, you'll see 1999 as a starting date for the EPA involvement in Libby.
What makes that interesting is that we've KNOWN asbestos was a carcinogen since 1975. It wasn't a secret. The mining company knew their workers were exposed. But they made as much money, as quickly as they could...and worried about the lawsuits (if any) later. Nope...no Unions...not in that town.
The people who died acquired asbestosis.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmedhealth/PMH0001177/
It's a nasty way to die. It's probably what will kill most of the 9-11 First Responders. That strange gray ash that fell everywhere? Asbestos. The Trade Center was FULL of the stuff...but they decided it was more risky to dig it out, than leave it in the walls...because Asbestos isn't an issue...unless it gets in the air.
Which it did...at 9-11...and Libby.
It Also got in the air when WR GRACE decided that the darker colored asbestos wasn't dangerous. So they sprayed the inside of their cargo bins with it...DECADES after the original asbestos ban. The result? More dead and dying workers. But THAT case is a fun one. They have managed to keep it out of the courts for 20 years...long enough for most of the victims to die. (Their suit dies with them, of course.) They have argued that they were not responsible...and even if they WERE responsible, it was their Insurance Company's job to pay the claims. The Insurance Company has argued that until a certain threshold of claim was reached, they are off the hook. OTHER industries have argued that someone else is responsible. And in the mean time, the people they poisoned still die.
Nice trick, really.
Now...a recap. Mining. Insurance. Paint Manufacture. Construction. Shipping. Several industries, all allegedly "regulated". All making monster profits, while their workers paid for it quite literally, with their lives. That's not counting the police, firemen, EMT's, or other workers who were at 9-11.
And now the REAL kicker. YOUR taxes paid for the Libby Clean up...because the company declared bankruptcy!
Now tell me again how all this evil regulation is hurting INDUSTRY?
Oh...and do have more than theory....
Recent Comments